Welcome to Frosted by Maddie, a trusted Bakery and Cake Shop in Terre Haute, IN, where quality service and helpful guidance come first. With a 4.80-star rating from 93 reviews, we’re proud to support customers with Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance and various amenities.
Our Specialties
Every dish tells a story. Explore our carefully curated menu featuring seasonal favorites and signature creations.
Our chef's signature creations featuring locally-sourced ingredients and innovative culinary techniques.
We partner with local farmers and suppliers to bring you the freshest seasonal ingredients every day.
Every plate is prepared with attention to detail, combining traditional recipes with modern presentation.
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Hear from our valued guests
I’m an out of town college student living in Massachusetts, and I received some cookies through their new shipment platform. Oh. My. Gosh. What a delight! The cookies are delicious and I’ve found myself so grateful to have a family member who’s willing to order me cookies all the way from Illinois. I highly recommend this establishment! The owner is especially helpful and very friendly.
My son and I stopped by Frosted By Maddie’s for the first time and got a Cinnamon Roll Cookie. It was absolutely amazing! We spoke with the owner. She is so kind and sweet. Highly recommend! We will definitely be back!
Surely you wouldn't expect to have a bakey that prepares anything truly decadent in a small town like Terre Haute, but having that idea in your head would be dead wrong. Maddie and her team at Frosted by Maddie should be hired to bake cookies and cakes for royalty. They should be at the inaugural soiree in White House ballroom if you swing that way. THEY'RE PRODUCTS ARE THAT GOOD! ordered a cake for my 7 year old son's birthday, and what was delivered was a beautiful cake that was surely far too good for the likes of us. Addiction causingly delicious buttercream icing on a cake that had to be two feet tall! Three layers of the most moist yet soft chocolate cake inside. I don't have the words to describe how good that cake was, but I know we all sat silently, in elation, at a bowling alley of all places to eat what should be reserved for Gods. I live an hour and a half away from the bakery, but I'd gladly drive there every day to eat just a cookie, if not more cake. Lucky for me, and the rest of the household, it was a huge cake so we got to take a sizable portion home with us. That cake lasted and stayed just as moist and decadent an entire week later when we finally finished it. Truly amazing. If anyone, and I mean ANYONE, asked me where to order any type of sweet treat for a party or event they will receive the number from Frosted by Maddie from me. Here or in Terre Haute. Great people. Great cookies. Great cakes. What a great place. If I could give a million stars, I would. Amazing!
If you're going anywhere else on this earth to get cookies, then you need to be rethinking all of your life decisions. The reeses cookie I got was by far, hands down, the absolute best cookie I've ever had and will have in my entire life. My only complaint is that the cookie isn't the size of a frisbee. 1,000/10 recommend. Will be back too many times to count. Cant get enough. To the owner and workers, thank you for giving me such a massive amount of joy in my life in the form of a little cookie that completely changed my world. Best cookies ever. I forever hope your pillow stays cold and your favorite pair of socks never disappear in the dryer. Thank you.
I received 3 cookies shipped from Frosted by Maddie. They arrived well packaged, and absolutely delicious. They were incredibly fresh, and looked like they were baked that very morning. I look forward to ordering more cookies, and would highly recommend utilizing Frosted by Maddie for all your cookie needs!
Maddie created a beautiful dye free mermaid themed cake for my little girl's first birthday. She communicated with me well. The cake was delicious! Prices were reasonable. This was the only place in town that was willing to make a dye free cake. We appreciate it!! Can't wait to have more goodies by Maddie!
I got the brown sugar pop tart cookie, the cinnamon roll cookie, and the Little Debbie Christmas Tree cheesecake. So, so delicious! They have so many unique, and tasty desserts. The cheesecake is so good and rich. Definitely recommend to anyone looking to satisfy their sweet tooth!
Frosted by Maddie is one of those small businesses that reminds you why shopping local matters. Every dessert feels thoughtfully made — from the moist cakes and beautifully decorated cookies to treat boxes filled with the perfect variety. MYou can taste the care and pride put into each order. What truly sets Frosted by Maddie apart is the heart behind it. Maddie and her team bring a personal touch you just don’t get from big chains — friendly service, attention to detail, and a genuine passion for what they do. When you support Frosted by Maddie, you’re not just getting an amazing dessert, you’re supporting a local dream and a business that pours love into the community. If you believe in supporting small businesses and enjoying incredible homemade-style treats, Frosted by Maddie is absolutely worth it. 💗
In the past month I’ve ordered gender reveal cupcakes and a 6” cake from Frosted by Maddie. Let me tell you, I won’t be ordering from anywhere else ever again!! Not only are Maddie and her staff an absolute delight, but these are the best baked goods I’ve ever had!! Both were custom orders and they were perfect. One of my sisters is gluten free and I asked if there was any way I could order a small batch of gender reveal cookies just for her. Maddie was beyond helpful and offered to make one single cookie with an icing center, just so she could be included in the reveal. It was also delicious!! I’ve never gotten so many compliments before on the quality and taste of both the cupcakes and the carrot cake. The cake melts in your mouth and the icing was heaven! The icing on the cake, pun intended, was the price. Their cost for each order was so reasonable I thought I misheard her quote. Needless to say, I’m going to let Frosted by Maddie take care of all baking in the future.
I ordered a fruit pizza for our son’s graduation from another parent’s recommendation and was completely blown away! Not only was it delicious, but it was absolutely beautiful! We were so pleased! I would definitely recommend this bakery!
Common questions about Frosted by Maddie
Frosted by Maddie is located at 3315 S 7th St, Terre Haute, IN 47802, United States, Terre Haute, IN, United States.
You can reach Frosted by Maddie by calling +1 812-298-4616.
Frosted by Maddie has a rating of 4.8 out of 5 based on 93 customer reviews.
Frosted by Maddie features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance.
Frosted by Maddie features the following service options: On-site services, Takeaway, Delivery.
Frosted by Maddie features the following planning: Quick visit.
Frosted by Maddie features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards.
Frosted by Maddie features the following parking: Free parking lot.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
